Method & Sources · methodology v1.1
European Space Autonomy Tracker
Calculation — Attainment of 2036 target level
- Per-KPI attainment (0–100). Higher is better: latest ÷ target. Lower is better (KPI 05): target ÷ latest. Clamped to 0–100%.
- Conflicting evidence no longer excludes a KPI: the most conservative documented value of the latest reporting period (the one giving lower attainment) is used, and the full range is shown.
- Eligibility. Excluded: threat indicators without a target, KPIs without a baseline or latest value, estimates, values pending verification, outdated values, KPIs without target or target year. Excluded KPIs are listed and never counted as zero.
- Equal weighting. The meter is 100 × the unweighted mean of eligible KPIs. No defensible evidence exists for relative weights. Each KPI sits in one pillar only. Pillar dials use the same formula within each pillar.
- Publication rule. The meter is shown only when at least 5 of 12 KPIs are eligible.
- Confidence is the median confidence of contributing KPIs, capped at Medium when any rests on partially verified or conflicting evidence. Reported separately from the score.
- Secondary measure. Progress since baseline (method v1.0) is kept on KPI pages and below, but not used for the meter, because most latest values still equal their baselines.
- Targets are group hypotheses for 2036, not adopted policy targets.
Methodology decisions
Append-only record of decisions that change eligibility or calculation.
- 12 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 01Reported range 7–9; midpoint 8 used. Project group brief: a single value is shown on rows, tiles, meter and path calculations; the full reported range remains visible in the KPI drawer and on the Method page. — Project group (KPI page brief)
- 10 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 11KPI 11 added with case figures; shown in the homepage mosaic with its attainment but excluded from the meter until a Tier 1 or Tier 2 source supports the value. Case figures are not independent evidence; adding them must not move the meter. — Project group (Phase 10 brief)
- 10 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 12KPI 12 added with case figures (share derived from about €230m of about €10.9bn); shown in the mosaic but excluded from the meter until a Tier 1 or Tier 2 source supports the value. Case figures are not independent evidence; adding them must not move the meter. — Project group (Phase 10 brief)
- 10 Nov 2026 · v1.1KPIs 09 and 10 move from the homepage mosaic to a Development pipeline on the KPI page; their records and exclusion from the meter are unchanged. The homepage shows only indicators with values; unmeasured indicators keep a documented path to a baseline. — Project group (Phase 10 brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 10Target year set to 2036. The group defined all targets for 2036. KPI 10 nevertheless stays excluded because its value is an estimate. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 09Target applies to relevant equipment procured after 2030; no target year assigned to the share. KPI 09 has no baseline or latest value and is shown as monitored, not scored. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1Meter measures attainment of the 2036 target level: higher is better = clamp(latest/target,0,1); lower is better = clamp(target/latest,0,1); equal-weighted mean ×100. Most latest values still equal their baselines, so progress-since-baseline (v1.0) cannot yet discriminate. Progress since baseline is kept as a secondary measure on KPI pages. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1Estimates stay excluded until a verifiable source supports them; threat indicators without a target and KPIs without baseline or latest value are monitored, not scored. Prevents unverified or non-directional values entering the meter. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1Conflicting evidence no longer excludes a KPI: the most conservative documented value of the latest period (lowest attainment) is used, the full reported range is shown, and confidence stays Medium or Low. Excluding disputed KPIs hid information; the conservative value avoids overstating progress. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1Meter is published only when at least 5 of 10 KPIs are eligible. Minimum evidence coverage before any composite figure is shown. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 03Target year set to 2036. The group defined all targets for 2036. Documented group decision, not new data. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
- 9 Nov 2026 · v1.1 · KPI 06Target year set to 2036. The group defined all targets for 2036. Documented group decision, not new data. — Project group (Phase 6 revised brief)
Current result
Calculated live from the KPI records · 7 of 12 KPIs eligible
- Meter
- 48% of 2036 target level
- Evidence coverage
- 58.3%
- Confidence
- Medium
- Mean of eligible KPIs
- 48 (shown for transparency only)
- Confidence is the median confidence of the contributing KPIs.
- Some contributing KPIs rest on partially verified or conflicting evidence, so confidence is capped at Medium.
- Low-confidence contributors: KPI 01.
Contributing KPIs
Equal weight each.
| KPI | Value used → target | Attainment | Since baseline |
|---|---|---|---|
| KPI 01 European orbital launches per year | 8 → 20 (2036) · reported range 7–9, midpoint used | 40% · contributes 5.7 pts | 0% |
| KPI 02 Operational European launch providers | 2 → 3 (2036) | 66.7% · contributes 9.5 pts | 0% |
| KPI 03 European share of capital raised in European space funding rounds | 69 → 90 (2036) | 76.7% · contributes 11 pts | 0% |
| KPI 04 Private capital raised by European space companies per year | 1.4 → 3.5 (2036) | 40% · contributes 5.7 pts | 0% |
| KPI 05 Foreign buyers in acquisitions of European space companies | 35 → 15 (2036) | 42.9% · contributes 6.1 pts | 0% |
| KPI 06 SMEs' share of European Defence Fund funding | 21 → 30 (2036) | 70% · contributes 10 pts | 0% |
| KPI 07 IRIS² satellites deployed | 0 → 100 (2036) | 0% · contributes 0 pts | 0% |
Excluded KPIs
Not counted as zero; reasons shown.
- KPI 08 European air traffic exposed to GNSS interference
Threat indicator without an autonomy target
- KPI 09 New critical-infrastructure navigation equipment supporting authenticated GNSS
Source verification pending / no reliable source · No documented baseline · No latest observation · No target year
- KPI 10 Business users' share of active Copernicus data users
Value is an estimate · Source verification pending / no reliable source
- KPI 11 Public space spending as a share of GDP
Value is an estimate · Source verification pending / no reliable source
- KPI 12 Share of European public space money under direct EU control
Value is an estimate · Source verification pending / no reliable source
Pillar mapping
Each KPI is assigned to exactly one pillar.
- Can Europe reach orbit on its own?
- KPI 01, KPI 0253.4% · 2 of 2 scorable
- Who finances and controls European space?
- KPI 03, KPI 04, KPI 05, KPI 06, KPI 10, KPI 11, KPI 1257.4% · 4 of 7 scorable
- Is Europe's space infrastructure secure and resilient?
- KPI 07, KPI 08, KPI 090% · 1 of 2 scorable
Tracker history
Append-only snapshots. Scores from different method versions are not comparable. No history is back-filled.
| Date | Version | Score | Coverage | Confidence | Eligible | Excluded |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Nov 2026 | v1.1 | 47.3% | 70% | Medium | KPI 01, KPI 02, KPI 03, KPI 04, KPI 05, KPI 06, KPI 07 | KPI 08, KPI 09, KPI 10 |
| 9 Nov 2026 | v1.0 | Not published | 40% | Low | KPI 02, KPI 04, KPI 05, KPI 07 | KPI 01, KPI 03, KPI 06, KPI 08, KPI 09, KPI 10 |
Reviewers can record a new snapshot after signing in.
KPI source audit
For every KPI: the value-supporting sources, their governance tier and verification status. Figures were not replaced; weak support is flagged.
Tier 1 · Official primary
EU institutions, ESA, EUROCONTROL, EASA, national agencies, official filings.
Tier 2 · Research institution
ESPI, OECD; may support values where official data is unavailable.
Tier 3 · Specialist industry / financial
Seraphim, financial databases, trade press; caveats required.
Tier 4 · General media
Context and corroboration only; cannot establish a baseline.
- KPI 01 European orbital launches per year⚑ Conflicting evidence⚑ Conflicting evidence — methodological clarification required
Displayed: 7–9 (conflicting evidence) · Calendar year 2025 · Scope: Europe (European launch providers; launch sites in and outside Europe)
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“9 European orbital launches in 2025; SpaceX 175; China 94.”Period: 2025 · Limitations: No counting rule or source given.⚑ Conflicting evidence
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: Europe's Spaceport 2025 reviewEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · published 13 Mar 2026“Lists four Ariane 6 and three Vega-C launches from Europe's Spaceport in 2025 (e.g. "1 December: launch of Kompsat-7 satellite"; "17 December: 14th launch of Galileo satellites").”Period: 2025 · Limitations: Total is derived by counting listed launches; ESA does not state a Europe-wide total. Excludes launches from other sites.⚑ Partially verified
- secondary · Tier 4 · General mediaArs Technica Rocket Report: 2025 year in reviewArs Technica · published 9 Jan 2026“"Europe with eight"; "SpaceX launched 165 Falcon 9 rockets in 2025"; "In addition to five Starship-Super Heavy launches"; "China, which attempted 92 orbital launches in 2025".”Period: 2025 · Limitations: Counting rule (attempts vs successes; provider vs site) not stated.✓ Verified secondary source
- KPI 02 Operational European launch providers⚑ Partially verified✓ Supported by Tier 1 official evidence
Displayed: 2 operational (Arianespace, Avio) + 1 orbit-proven (Isar Aerospace) · Status documented up to 9 September 2026 · Scope: Europe (providers headquartered and controlled in Europe, EU and non-EU)
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“Arianespace and Isar Aerospace listed as European providers (2025).”Period: 2025 · Limitations: No definition of "operational" given.⚑ Conflicting evidence
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryIsar Aerospace press release: Spectrum first test flightIsar Aerospace · published 30 Mar 2025“First Spectrum flight "was terminated at T+30 seconds and fell directly into the sea in controlled manner."”Period: 30 March 2025 · Limitations: Company disclosure about its own flight.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: Vega-C programme pageEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · publication date not recorded“"Arianespace was responsible for commercial exploitation of the launch system until 2026 when Avio started to take over."”Period: Until 2026 · Limitations: Undated page.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: Ariane 6 and Vega-C exploitation arrangementsEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · published 14 Nov 2025“Arrangements signed "one with Arianespace and ArianeGroup for Ariane 6, and one with Avio for Vega-C"; Avio assumes "additional responsibilities for selling and operating the Vega launch service."”Period: From 14 November 2025 · Limitations: Classification of Avio as an independent provider depends on ownership/control definition.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: Spectrum lifts offEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · published 9 Sept 2026“"German company Isar Aerospace successfully reached orbit with their Spectrum launcher, lifting off from Andøya Spaceport in Norway on 5 September 2026."”Period: 5 September 2026 · Limitations: Establishes orbital success, not operational readiness.✓ Verified primary source
- KPI 03 European share of capital raised in European space funding rounds✓ Verified primary evidence✓ Supported by Tier 2 research evidence (no official source located)
Displayed: 69% · 2024–2025 (two-year period) · Scope: European space ventures (ESPI coverage); investor origin by lead investor
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI Report 102: Space Venture 2025 (full report)European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · publication date not recorded“"Only 69% of the ~€2 billion venture capital raised in the past two years in Europe was secured in rounds led by European investors. Meanwhile, in the US, that figure rises to above 90%."”Period: 2024–2025 · Limitations: Lead-investor basis: full round value attributed to lead investor origin. ESPI tracked dataset.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI Report 102: Space Venture 2025 (full report)European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · publication date not recorded“"Of the 9 European space venture scaleup rounds in 2025, five were led by European public entities"; "all four remaining deals anchored by private investors were led by American investors."”Period: 2025 · Limitations: Applies to ESPI-tracked scaleup rounds only; "growth round" in the brief may be defined differently.✓ Verified primary source
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“69% European share 2024–2025; US 90%+; no 2025 growth round led by a European private investor.”Period: 2024–2025 · Limitations: Definition not stated.⚑ Partially verified
- KPI 04 Private capital raised by European space companies per year⚑ Partially verified✓ Supported by Tier 2 research evidence (no official source located)
Displayed: €1.4bn · 2025 · Scope: European space ventures (ESPI coverage)
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI: Space Venture Europe 2023European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · published 22 May 2024“"The space sector raised €942 million, representing a 7% decrease in investment in 2023."”Period: 2023 (with comparison to 2022) · Limitations: ESPI totals include public and mixed investor participation; not exclusively private capital. 2022 value implied, not stated.⚑ Partially verified
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI: Space Venture Europe 2023European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · published 22 May 2024“2022 value of about €1.0bn implied by the reported 7% decrease to €942m in 2023.”Period: 2022 · Limitations: Derived; exact 2022 figure not located.⚑ Partially verified
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI: Space Venture 2024European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · published 20 Jun 2025“"Attracting €1.5 billion"; "over 80% of the capital secured in Europe came from public or mixed investor consortia."”Period: 2024 · Limitations: Not exclusively private capital.⚑ Partially verified
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI: Space Venture 2025 report pageEuropean Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · published 5 May 2026“"Europe's space ventures attracted €1.4 billion in 2025"; "Venture capital…grew by 13% to €1.2 billion."”Period: 2025 · Limitations: Not exclusively private capital.⚑ Partially verified
- contextual · Tier 3 · Specialist industry / financialJumpseat Aerospace News: European space-tech funding H1 2026Jumpseat Aerospace News · published 12 Aug 2026“"European space-tech companies raised €2.9 billion"; "Debt financing accounted for 45.6% of the total."”Period: H1 2026 · Limitations: Secondary report of Tech.eu data; includes debt; half-year; different coverage from ESPI.⚑ Partially verified
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“ESPI figures 2022 €1.0bn, 2023 €0.94bn, 2024 €1.5bn, 2025 €1.4bn; Tech.eu H1 2026 €2.9bn incl. debt.”Period: 2022–2026 · Limitations: Supplied summary.⚑ Partially verified
- KPI 05 Foreign buyers in acquisitions of European space companies⚑ Partially verified✓ Supported by Tier 2 research evidence (no official source located)
Displayed: 35% · 2014–2025 (cumulative) · Scope: Target companies: Europe (EU and non-EU). Buyer origin: headquarters outside Europe.
- primary · Tier 2 · Research institutionESPI Report 102: Space Venture 2025 (full report)European Space Policy Institute (ESPI) · publication date not recorded“"Of the 46 tracked acquisitions of European space companies over the 2014-2025 period, around a third (35%) involved foreign acquirers, predominantly US-based."”Period: 2014–2025 · Limitations: "Foreign" may not equal "non-European"; completion and control-transfer status not confirmed; cumulative only.⚑ Partially verified
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“Approximately one-third of acquisitions since 2014 by foreign buyers.”Period: Since 2014 · Limitations: Supplied summary.⚑ Partially verified
- KPI 06 SMEs' share of European Defence Fund funding✓ Verified primary evidence✓ Supported by Tier 1 official evidence
Displayed: >21% · EDF 2025 calls (results April 2026) · Scope: EU (European Defence Fund; EU Member States and associated countries)
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryEuropean Commission: EDF 2025 call resultsEuropean Commission (DG DEFIS) · published 15 Apr 2026“"SMEs are central to this round, making up over 38% of participants and receiving more than 21% of the total funding."”Period: EDF 2025 calls · Limitations: Whole EDF; not space-specific. Lower bounds.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryEuropean Commission: EDF 2023 call results factsheetEuropean Commission (DG DEFIS) · publication date not recorded“"Strong SME involvement: 42% of all entities selected with 18% of total funding to SMEs."”Period: EDF 2023 calls · Limitations: Whole EDF; not space-specific. Participation basis ("entities selected") may differ from 2025 ("participants").✓ Verified primary source
- KPI 07 IRIS² satellites deployed⚑ Partially verified✓ Supported by Tier 1 official evidence
Displayed: 0 of at least 348 (inferred) · As described by ESA, 30 October 2026 · Scope: EU (IRIS² is an EU programme; ESA is a partner, not an EU institution)
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: IRIS² programme pageEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · published 30 Oct 2026“"Multi-orbital constellation of at least 348 satellites"; "at least 330 satellites located in low Earth orbit (LEO) and 18 in medium Earth orbit (MEO)"; "With launches starting in 2029 and early services starting to be provided in 2030".”Period: Programme description, 30 October 2026 · Limitations: Zero deployed is inferred from the launch schedule, not stated.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryESA: IRIS² programme pageEuropean Space Agency (ESA) · published 30 Oct 2026“Launches starting in 2029 (implies no IRIS² satellites deployed as of October 2026).”Period: As of 30 October 2026 · Limitations: Inference.⚑ Partially verified
- secondary · Tier 1 · Official primaryEuropean Commission: IRIS² concession signatureEuropean Commission (DG DEFIS) · published 16 Dec 2024“"A multi-orbital constellation of 290 satellite[s]"; "governmental and commercial connectivity services by 2030."”Period: 16 December 2024 · Limitations: Earlier design description.⚑ Conflicting evidence
- KPI 08 European air traffic exposed to GNSS interference⚑ Outdated evidence✓ Supported by Tier 1 official evidence
Displayed: 38% · 2021 (latest documented) · Scope: European airspace (EUROCONTROL network area, wider than the EU)
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryEUROCONTROL: GNSS webinar introductionEUROCONTROL · publication date not recorded“"38.5% of European en-route traffic operates through regions intermittently, but regularly affected by RFI"; "5% of traffic in these regions could, given current RFI levels, need special assistance."”Period: H2 2020 · Limitations: Exposure, not disruption. Based on Airbus detection data. Presentation material. Outdated.✓ Verified primary source
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryEUROCONTROL: Monitoring GNSS RF InterferenceEUROCONTROL · publication date not recorded“"Can affect around 38% of European Network Traffic."”Period: 1 January–31 December 2021 · Limitations: Exposure, not disruption. Approximate. Presentation material. Outdated.✓ Verified primary source
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“38% of European air traffic exposed; up to 40% also referenced.”Period: Not stated · Limitations: Supplied summary.⚑ Source verification pending
- KPI 09 New critical-infrastructure navigation equipment supporting authenticated GNSS⚑ Source verification pending⚑ Insufficient verified evidence
Displayed: Not yet measured · no reporting period · Scope: EU Member States (critical entities)
- contextual · Tier 1 · Official primaryEUSPA press release: OSNMA service launchEU Agency for the Space Programme (EUSPA) · published 22 Jul 2025“"Forthcoming official launch…on 24 July"; "While OSNMA does not prevent spoofing or jamming, it makes spoofing significantly harder by authenticating the data".”Period: Service launch 24 July 2025 · Limitations: Context for the KPI; does not measure equipment uptake.✓ Verified primary source
- contextual · Tier 1 · Official primaryEUSPA news: OSNMA protection against interferenceEU Agency for the Space Programme (EUSPA) · published 22 Jul 2025“"While the OSNMA does increase the ability to detect spoofing events, it does not prevent their occurrence. Nor does it protect against jamming."”Period: 2025 · Limitations: Context only.✓ Verified primary source
- KPI 10 Business users' share of active Copernicus data users⚑ Source verification pending✓ Supported by Tier 1 official evidence
Displayed: 7% (unverified) · Period not stated · Scope: EU programme (global user base)
- input · Supplied input — not evidencePhase 1 KPI framework (supplied research)Project owner (internal brief) · publication date not recorded“Companies 7%, researchers 64% of Copernicus users; 289,000 registered users in 2024.”Period: Not stated (2024 for users) · Limitations: Denominator and period not stated.⚑ Source verification pending
- primary · Tier 1 · Official primaryCopernicus Data Space Ecosystem: Annual Report 2024 releaseCopernicus Data Space Ecosystem · published 4 Dec 2025“"289,000 users registered in 2024."”Period: 2024 · Limitations: Registered users of one platform, not active users; not a business share.✓ Verified primary source
- secondary · Tier 1 · Official primaryCopernicus Data Space Ecosystem: Annual Report 2024Copernicus Data Space Ecosystem (operating consortium) · publication date not recorded“"Registered users soared from 84,000 to almost 290,000."”Period: 2024 · Limitations: Registered stock; not active users.✓ Verified primary source
- contextual · Tier 1 · Official primaryEUSPA: EU Space and an autonomous UnionEU Agency for the Space Programme (EUSPA) · published 23 Jan 2026“"GNSS and Earth Observation combined global revenues set to increase from more than EUR 260 billion in 2023 to nearly EUR 590 billion by 2033."”Period: 2023–2033 (projection) · Limitations: Projection; not Copernicus-only, not Europe-only, not a range. Not a KPI value.✓ Verified primary source
- KPI 11 Public space spending as a share of GDP⚑ Source verification pending⚑ Insufficient verified evidence
Displayed: 0.07% of GDP (case figure) · 2025 (reporting year to be confirmed) · Scope: Europe (EU, ESA and national budgets)
- ⚑ No source recorded.
- KPI 12 Share of European public space money under direct EU control⚑ Source verification pending⚑ Insufficient verified evidence
Displayed: about 2% (€230m of €10.9bn, case figures) · 2025 (reporting year to be confirmed) · Scope: Europe (EU, ESA and national budgets)
- ⚑ No source recorded.